Story
Haert
Caspar Otten | Corporate Counsel at Haert, part of Driessen Group
Story
Caspar Otten | Corporate Counsel at Haert, part of Driessen Group
Many foundations and associations hire freelancers without knowing exactly what is involved. This can have significant consequences, warns corporate lawyer Caspar Otten, who works at Haert , Supportpunt's CSR partner. During Supportpunt's information evening on April 15, 2025, he shared insights regarding the laws and regulations surrounding freelancers and bogus self-employment.
Haert supports organizations with all external hiring issues, particularly by carefully examining the legal aspects and risks involved in working with self-employed professionals. “We create control over hiring for our clients,” says Caspar. “Whether it concerns freelancers, secondment, or affiliation with an employment agency – we arrange it. Our goal is to act as a sort of hiring director.” Caspar finds the laws and regulations surrounding freelancers vague and unclear. “We ensure proper file building and checks on the freelancer. Does he have a Chamber of Commerce registration? Does he work for multiple clients? These are all elements the Tax Authorities look at to determine whether there is a case of bogus self-employment.”
According to Caspar, many misunderstandings arise from the concept itself: the Act (Deregulation of the Assessment of Employment Relationships), or the DBA Act. “People often say colloquially: the DBA Act is being enforced, and then you hear the term bogus self-employment. But from a legal perspective, that is incorrect,” he explains. “The Tax and Customs Administration checks whether an employment contract exists – that is mandatory law. And if that is the case, as the client, you must withhold payroll tax.”
Whether an employment contract exists is determined based on three elements: wages, an obligation to perform personal work, and authority. “If those three elements are present in practice, there is an employment relationship – even if you have agreed otherwise on paper.”
In 2023, the so-called Deliveroo ruling was an important judgment. The judge ruled that an employment contract existed, even though the delivery drivers worked as self-employed contractors. “The assessment is always holistic – you have to look at all the circumstances, and you don’t know in advance which element carries more weight.” That makes it difficult, according to Caspar: “One self-employed contractor might be independent on an assignment, while another isn’t, simply because they have no other work or have just left employment with the same client.”
For foundations and associations, other complications also come into play. “They often work extensively with volunteers, and the distinction between volunteering, salaried employment, and self-employment is not always clear. A small mistake can have major consequences.” A concrete example? “Suppose a self-employed person does a few odd jobs every week for 200 euros. That seems non-committal, but if he has no other clients and you determine what he does and when, the Tax Authorities may view that as salaried employment.”
Foundations and associations face additional points of attention. “For instance, they often work with volunteers, and the distinction between volunteer work, salaried employment, and self-employment is not always clear. A small mistake can quickly have major consequences.” An example: suppose a self-employed person does odd jobs weekly for 200 euros for years. “That might seem harmless, but if he has no other clients and you determine what he does and when, the Tax Authorities may classify this as employment. This can lead to back taxes and fines.”
And that risk is not hypothetical. Caspar: “In a case I know, a freelancer had been working on a website for a foundation for years. When the collaboration ended, he claimed 150.000 euros – successfully – because, according to the judge, he was actually an employee in practice.”
The damages resulting from a claim can be substantial. “The Tax and Customs Administration claims the payroll taxes. Additionally, if you fall under a specific mandatory collective labour agreement or pension scheme, you may also receive a claim from the pension fund.”
Since the introduction of the DBA Act in 2016, responsibility lies with both the client and the contractor. “Previously, there was the VAR declaration. With that, the Tax and Customs Administration provided clarity in advance. With that document, as a client, you knew how to handle payroll tax. Now you have to assess that yourself. And therefore, bear the risks yourself as well.”
“Pay attention to authority,” he emphasizes. “If, as a client, you determine how something needs to be done – for example, which tools someone should use or what time they need to be at the office – then you are exercising authority. That is one of the key points on which you are judged.”
“End the collaboration immediately,” advises Caspar. “If that isn’t possible—for example, if someone holds a very prominent role within your organization—then have a conversation with your freelancer. See if there is an option to turn it into an employment relationship. If that doesn’t work, ensure that the agreements with the freelancer are put down more clearly on paper. And that those agreements are actually correct in practice.”
A model agreement is an agreement approved by the Tax and Customs Administration that outlines the legal relationship between the client and the contractor. The website Hetjuistecontract.nl and the Web module for assessing the employment relationship are also useful.
“Absolutely,” says Caspar. “You have to use common sense when looking at the reason you are hiring someone and the duration of the assignment. Make sure to put your agreements and considerations in writing. Why are you hiring someone and what have you agreed upon? Also, collect your freelancers’ details: a Chamber of Commerce extract and an insurance policy. Show that you have thought it through carefully and done your research.”
Does a self-employed professional have a Chamber of Commerce registration? Does he work for multiple clients? These are all elements that the Tax and Customs Administration considers to determine whether there is a case of bogus self-employment.